Memoir

Shame and Forgiveness

     I loved my first grade teacher. Her name was Mrs. Wilke. She was kind, caring and gentle. I was willing to do anything for her.

     One of the treats in first grade was to be chosen to flick the lights in the gym to let everyone know that recess was over. During the winter when outside temperatures were below freezing, our fifteen minute recesses were spent in the school gym. We played games and ran off pent up energy. I’m sure most considered this our favorite part of the school day.

     One day I was chosen to flick the lights at the end of recess. What an honor! Mrs. Wilke selected me out of the entire class to carry out this trusted responsibility. I flicked the light switch, the lights blinked, and everyone charged out of the gym back to the classroom. Only as I passed Mrs. Wilke, she grabbed my hand and pulled me aside. “Why did you flick the lights? Recess isn’t over yet.” 

      I was sure she told me to carry out this important task. I was humiliated. I failed her, and all of my classmates looked at me with annoyance. I had cut short their recess!

     In looking back, I know this trivial event affected the rest of my life. To this day, I fear making gaffes in front of others. That one moment of embarrassment is still crystal clear in my mind. Yet, I realize that I was only a child and made a simple mistake. It was not earth shattering and had no lingering effects on others. I am sure that not one of my classmates or my teacher could recall the event at a later time. Mrs. Wilke did not chastise me for it; she treated me with kindness and forgiveness. My long remembered shame was totally my own doing. Forgiving myself is long overdue. If only the mistakes I made later in life were so insignificant.

9 Comments

  • Fran Randolph

    Thank you for this blog. We all blame ourselves for mistakes of the past. I have been in an amazing coaching program which helps people deal with life challenges. It is similar to positive psychology and CBT and helps people identify and reduce the negative voices we continue to hold onto so as to experience more joy, calmness and peace of mind. Thousands of coaches around the world are being trained in this model which I think can have a profound impact on all of us. If you want to know more about it, go to http://www.positiveintelligence.com.

  • Michele Edwards

    Carole, Thank you for the reminder of our learning. Trauma may be a later treasure.

    One of my key learning points was in kindergarten with Mrs. Bird, we had 50 in the class and met in the High School gym. It was painful but I learn a life lesson remembered to this day — and treasure it — glad I learned it early I have used and adapted it many times.

    • Carole

      That is a very large class. I see that you still remember the incident too. I am glad you could use the learnings later in your life. I like your concept that trauma may be a later treasure. I think that is a very positive and healthy way of looking at it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.